Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Joseph Vaz's avatar

NTT: I don't know that a Sanctus text is exactly a "dead giveaway..." but noting the slow tempo, the full brass section, and the Romantic harmony in conjunction with the history-textbook mention, I'll guess: Reinecke, Franck, and Rubinstein.

Expand full comment
Jeremy Rosenberg's avatar

Absolutely loved all the analysis on my NTT last week, it was all spot on, even if the actual composer’s name eluded everyone. We’ll see if I manage to make any guesses in Will’s submission for this week.

On Schumann’s advice, I’m afraid I just cannot follow it unless an emendation is made so that it reads:

“Love your instrument, but do not be vain enough to consider it the greatest and only one…unless your instrument is the clarinet, which everyone knows is the best.”

(I will, however, concede agreement with the sentiment that choral music with orchestra is the most sublime.)

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts