Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Eric Breon's avatar

NTT: I’m actually going to go the German route and say Richard Strauss both because I could see this being written by him and because the “received narrative” about him usually dwells on his ties with the Third Reich, whereas I’d say he was an opportunist more than anything and with his anti-Weimer leanings would have been fine with the earlier Wilhelmin dynasty staying in power.

My other guesses are even further stretches: the clue at first had me thinking Wagner (perhaps despite his revolutionary leanings some monetary commission would have enticed him to write something) and then Liszt (I have it in his mind that he was more sympathetic to Hungarian folk culture but maybe he was fine with the Hapsburg). That’s all wild speculation, though.

Expand full comment
Joseph Vaz's avatar

NTT: This is super difficult from the sound - the melody is just weird sounding to me, and is quite suggestively modal despite the general major key. This suggests to me something outside of the typical Germanosphere, so I think I will double up on Tchaikovsky (uneasily), and add Smetana and Rimsky-Korsakov. (The hint doesn't help me :( )

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts